Cigars $12 and Up
For those looking to explore the premium end of the humidor, our $12 and up cigars bring together standout blends from established manufacturers and boutique cigar makers. From award-winning favorites to limited releases, these are cigars worth taking your time with. Great tobacco. Serious craftsmanship. No shortcuts.
If you’re looking for a cigar that leans bold, rich, and unapologetically full of flavor, the My Father The Judge Toro Fino delivers in a big way. ...
View full details4.67 / 5.0
3 Reviews
The Blackfoot feels built for the outdoors. This is a rich, grounded blend that leans into earth, wood, and steady strength without turning harsh. ...
View full detailsThe Montecristo White Series Toro is a smooth, mellow-to-medium cigar crafted with a silky Ecuadorian Connecticut Shade wrapper and a well-aged ble...
View full details4.67 / 5.0
3 Reviews
Ranked the #1 Cigar of the Year by Cigar Aficionado in 2020 with a jaw-dropping 98 rating, and the Pledge Apogee received the #11 Cigar of 2022. Th...
View full details5.0 / 5.0
2 Reviews
The My Father Le Bijou 1922 Torpedo is a full-bodied, box-pressed masterpiece that earned Cigar Aficionado’s #1 Cigar of the Year in 2015. Packed w...
View full detailsThe Cohiba Red Dot Robusto is a legendary Dominican cigar wrapped in rare African Cameroon leaf, known for its smooth draw, rich complexity, and im...
View full detailsIf bold maduro cigars are your thing, the Dunbarton Red Meat Lovers Ribeye is about as honest and flavorful as it gets. Built by Steve Saka to pair...
View full details4.67 / 5.0
3 Reviews
A cigar this good only comes around once every 60 years, literally. The Rocky Patel Sixty Toro celebrates the man behind the brand in bold, box-pre...
View full details4.75 / 5.0
4 Reviews
A decade of cigar excellence, wrapped in one unforgettable smoke. The Rocky Patel Decade Toro was created to celebrate 10 years of Rocky’s relentle...
View full details5.0 / 5.0
4 Reviews
Smooth, creamy, and effortlessly elegant, the Montecristo White Rothschilde is a refined take on a timeless classic. If you appreciate mellow cigar...
View full detailsEvery year, Bishop's Blend is one of the most anticipated releases from Black Label Trading Co., and for good reason. The 2026 edition celebrates t...
View full detailsIf you enjoy bold maduro cigars with real depth and character, the Black Label Trading Co. Last Rites Toro delivers exactly that kind of experience...
View full details4.67 / 5.0
3 Reviews
If you’re looking for a cigar that leans into bold Nicaraguan flavor with serious craftsmanship behind it, the Plasencia 1865 Alma Fuerte Robusto d...
View full details5.0 / 5.0
2 Reviews
When someone asks for a cigar that’s refined, balanced, and built on tradition, the Don Carlos line always enters the conversation. The Belicoso vi...
View full detailsPower meets polish in the Oliva Serie V Melanio Maduro Robusto. Rich, box-pressed, and full of flavor, this cigar delivers a refined strength that ...
View full detailsAn award-winning blend born from tradition and elevated by innovation, the Montecristo Nicaragua Toro (6" x 54) delivers a bold, full-bodied smokin...
View full detailsA modern, bold take on a classic name. Crafted under the guidance of master blender AJ Fernandez, the Montecristo Nicaragua Robusto delivers deep N...
View full details5.0 / 5.0
3 Reviews
The Tatuaje Miami Regios is a medium to full-bodied Nicaraguan puro handcrafted in Miami by Don “Pepin” Garcia and Pete Johnson. Built around class...
View full details4.75 / 5.0
4 Reviews
The Ashton VSG Robusto is a luxurious, full-bodied cigar made with rare, high-priming Ecuadorian Sumatra wrappers and aged Dominican fillers. Excep...
View full detailsRich cocoa, espresso, dark chocolate, and a touch of sweetness come together in the E.P. Carrillo La Historia E-III, a box-pressed Maduro that deli...
View full detailsThe Alec Bradley Gatekeeper Robusto brings together rich notes of cedar, leather, roasted nuts, and subtle sweetness in a balanced, medium-bodied c...
View full detailsThe Foundation Olmec Claro Robusto is rich and full-bodied, featuring a Mexican San Andrés Claro wrapper and Nicaraguan tobaccos from Estelí and Ja...
View full detailsThe E.P. Carrillo Ascend Ridge Toro is the latest addition to the Perez-Carrillo Series, joining favorites like Pledge, Encore, and La Historia. Wr...
View full detailsOz Family Maracana Robusto celebrates two lifelong passions of Tim Ozgener: exceptional cigars and the beautiful game. Handmade at My Father Cigars...
View full detailsEvery year, Bishop's Blend is one of the most anticipated releases from Black Label Trading Co., and the 2026 edition marks the blend's 10th annive...
View full detailsThe Tatuaje Reserva Broadleaf Unicos is a medium to full-bodied Nicaraguan cigar wrapped in rich Connecticut Broadleaf and handcrafted at the My Fa...
View full detailsIf you enjoy bold Nicaraguan cigars with rich earth, pepper, and natural sweetness, the Plasencia Alma del Fuego Candente is for you. Featuring rar...
View full detailsThe Black Label Trading Co. Salvation Toro brings that signature BLTC attitude in a smoother, slightly sweeter direction. It still has the spice, d...
View full detailsIf you’re looking for a cigar that delivers bold flavor with a refined edge, the Alec Bradley Prensado Gran Toro is one that’s earned its reputatio...
View full detailsIf you’re looking to branch out from the usual Nicaraguan-heavy profiles and try something with a different kind of depth, the My Father Blue Hondu...
View full detailsIf you’re looking for a step up from the classic Montecristo profile, the Montecristo Platinum Toro brings more body, more richness, and a deeper, ...
View full detailsIf you’re looking for a cigar that delivers consistency, smoothness, and a classic profile you can come back to anytime, the Montecristo Classic To...
View full detailsThe E.P. Carrillo Encore Majestic is a Nicaraguan puro that earned its place as Cigar Aficionado's #1 Cigar of 2018. It's both rich and balanced wi...
View full detailsIf you want the cigar that helped define modern Nicaraguan spice, this is it. The Don Pepín García Blue label is a direct reflection of Pepín Garcí...
View full detailsIf you’re the type of smoker who prefers cigars with depth and that old-school maduro character, the Mi Querida Ancho Largo is right in your wheelh...
View full detailsBold, full-bodied, and richly layered, Foundation The Tabernacle Toro features prized Connecticut Broadleaf over a powerful blend of Nicaraguan and...
View full detailsCrafted to honor a legacy and designed for the smokes-worthy moment, the Plasencia Cosecha 149 Azacualpa is rooted in history and built for flavor....
View full detailsSmooth, refined, and grounded in tradition, the Plasencia Alma del Campo Tribu Robusto captures the true spirit of Nicaraguan craftsmanship. Medium...
View full detailsA darker, richer evolution of the award-winning Mi Amor blend. The Reserva Belicoso delivers a more robust, full-bodied experience without losing t...
View full detailsThis isn’t just another cigar, it’s a legacy blend, handcrafted for those who know the difference. The Oliva Master Blends 3 Robusto is a rare, lim...
View full detailsBold, creamy, and rich in Cuban-style tradition, the Aganorsa Leaf Arsenio Robusto is a tribute to master blender Arsenio Ramos and everything he s...
View full detailsThe Ovation Eminence is a luxury-level, limited-edition cigar that pairs an ultra-dark San Andrés wrapper with rich Nicaraguan fillers, delivering ...
View full detailsAged in the same Nicaraguan puro blend, this box‑pressed torpedo amplifies texture and concentration for a richer hike through cedar, sweet cinnamo...
View full details5.0 / 5.0
2 Reviews
The Ashton VSG Torpedo is a full-bodied classic, masterfully constructed with a bold Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper and aged Dominican tobaccos. Packed...
View full detailsWhat You Get for $12 and Up
Every cigar in this collection starts at $12.00 per single, with five-pack and box options available on many selections.
You'll find premium blends from names like Arturo Fuente, Padrón, E.P. Carrillo, Plasencia, and other respected cigar makers. Expect a wide range of wrappers, strengths, and sizes, from smooth, balanced Connecticuts to rich Maduros and full-bodied Nicaraguan cigars.
Whether you're looking for something special to celebrate an occasion, trying a highly rated blend, or stocking your humidor with a longtime favorite, this collection gives you plenty to explore.
Looking for something at a lower price point? Browse our $10 to $12 cigars for more options.