Skip to content
Free Shipping on Orders Over $99
Free Shipping on Orders Over $99

What We're Smoking

These are the cigars we're reaching for right now. From everyday smokes to special occasion cigars, these are the blends we recommend most often.

See Our Picks

Smoked by us

Every cigar on this page has earned a spot in our rotation.

Staff Picks

These aren't just top sellers. They're cigars we actually recommend.

Updated regularly

As new cigars earn their place, this page evolves.

A brown paper package labeled "Umbagog," featuring an illustration of a plant, sits next to a single dark brown Connecticut Broadleaf cigar adorned with a green and white "Umbagog" band. The Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Umbagog Toro is the perfect everyday cigar for those who appreciate rich flavor and quality craftsmanship.
Daily Smoke

The Umbagog Toro is what we reach for when there's no occasion needed. Medium-bodied, consistently excellent, and priced where you can smoke it without thinking twice. If you're building a rotation, this is your anchor.

Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Umbagog Toro

$10.49
Shop Umbagog Toro
New To Cigars

If someone asks you where to start, this is the answer. Factory Smokes Shade delivers a smooth, creamy Connecticut experience at a price that makes it easy to explore without commitment.

No harshness, no complexity overload, just an approachable, well-made cigar that won't intimidate.

Factory Smokes by Drew Estate Shade Toro

$2.39
Shop Factory Smokes Shade
Best Value

The Charter Oak Maduro punches well above its price point. Rich, earthy, and full of dark chocolate and coffee notes, this is the cigar you hand someone when they say "I don't want to spend a lot but I want something good." Foundation nailed it with this one.

Foundation Charter Oak Maduro Toro

$7.29
Shop Charter Oak Maduro
Add a lifestyle image
Daily Smoke

A refined, medium-bodied smoke with notes of cedar, leather, and a hint of espresso. Perfect for unwinding after a long day.

Select a product to feature

The Full Rotation

A bundle of Factory Smokes by Drew Estate Shade Toro cigars with brown wrappers, neatly arranged upright in rows. These cigars feature black and white bands displaying the brand name, making them an attractive option for budget-conscious cigar enthusiasts. The selection is highlighted by the smooth Connecticut shade wrapper and approachable flavor profile of the Factory Smokes by Drew Estate Shade Toro.
Drew Estate Cigars

Factory Smokes by Drew Estate Shade Toro

$2.39 $2.55
A brown paper package labeled "Umbagog," featuring an illustration of a plant, sits next to a single dark brown Connecticut Broadleaf cigar adorned with a green and white "Umbagog" band. The Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Umbagog Toro is the perfect everyday cigar for those who appreciate rich flavor and quality craftsmanship.
Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust

Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Umbagog Toro

$10.49 $11.70
An open wooden box of Foundation Charter Oak Maduro Toro cigars reveals rows of Nicaraguan cigars adorned with branded bands. To the right, a single Foundation Charter Oak Maduro Toro—wrapped in a rich Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro—is displayed separately against a white background.
Foundation Cigar Company

Foundation Charter Oak Maduro Toro

$7.29 $7.99
An open box of Plasencia Alma del Fuego Candente cigars with one cigar displayed in the foreground; the box reveals several expertly crafted cigars made with rich Ometepe tobacco.
Plasencia Cigars

Plasencia Alma del Fuego Candente

$17.99 $19.95
An open box of Black Label Trading Co. Salvation Toro cigars displays a medium-profile cigar in close-up, both adorned with a praying hands and rose motif on the band and lid. Crafted with an Ecuadorian Sun Grown Habano wrapper, the Salvation Toro exemplifies distinctive character and artisanal design.
Black Label Trading Co.

Black Label Trading Co. Salvation Toro

$12.29
A wooden box of Tatuaje Miami Regios by Tatuaje, featuring brown-wrapped cigars with "Jalapa" bands; one Nicaraguan puro is partially removed and displayed separately.
Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje Miami Regios

$12.99 $14.99
A 5-pack of Iron Eagle Toro cigars lies atop a chaotic tangle of cables, wires, and tagged connectors—some marked with yellow tape—on a cluttered workspace, capturing the inventive essence of Chimera Concepts.
After Action Cigars

Iron Eagle Toro | 5-pack

$39.99 $42.99
A box of Plasencia 1865 Alma Fuerte Robusto Nicaraguan cigars is open, displaying neatly arranged cigars; one robusto cigar is shown in close-up on the right, highlighting its dark brown wrapper and branded band.
Plasencia Cigars

Plasencia 1865 Alma Fuerte Robusto

$20.99 $227.70
Black Label Trading Bishops Blend Robusto cigar with box
Black Label Trading Co.

Black Label Trading Co. 2026 Bishops Blend Robusto

$12.29
Black Label Trading Bishops Blend Corona Larga cigar with box
Black Label Trading Co.

Black Label Trading Co. 2026 Bishops Blend Corona Larga

$12.99

From The Cigar Academy