Skip to content
Free Shipping on Orders Over $99
Free Shipping on Orders Over $99

Best Selling Cigars

These are the cigars that earned their spot, the ones our customers reach for again and again. From mellow morning smokes to full-bodied powerhouses, every stick here has proven itself through real-world approval. When you’ve put in the work, you deserve a cigar that delivers every single time.

A single limited-edition TAG x After Action Maduro Toro cigar by After Action Cigars, featuring a white and black logo band, isolated on a white background.
A black resealable bag labeled "LOCKED. LOADED. LIT." sits next to the TAG x After Action Limited-Edition Cigar (5-Pack) from After Action Cigars, featuring a branded band and exclusive TAG Firearms collaboration.

TAG x After Action Limited-Edition Cigar (5-Pack)

After Action Cigars
$37.99
$37.99 - $37.99
$37.99
$32.99
$32.99 - $32.99
$32.99

A purpose-built collaboration between After Action Cigars and TAG Firearms, this limited-edition Maduro Toro is built for those who demand reliabil...

View full details
$37.99
$37.99 - $37.99
$37.99
$32.99
$32.99 - $32.99
$32.99
The Buffalo Trace Toro by Buffalo Trace is a medium-bodied brown cigar with a green band at one end and a portrait label—perfect for pairing with bourbon.
Open wooden box of Buffalo Trace Robusto cigars, featuring five premium hand-rolled cigars. Close-up shows the cigar band with buffalo illustration and Buffalo Trace branding, inspired by the legendary Kentucky bourbon.

Buffalo Trace Toro

Buffalo Trace Cigars
$8.29 - $165.99
$8.29 - $165.99
$8.29
$7.75 - $134.99
$7.75 - $134.99
$7.75

A bold pairing for bourbon lovers, the Buffalo Trace Toro brings the iconic whiskey brand’s signature richness to a medium-bodied, full-flavored ci...

View full details
$8.29 - $165.99
$8.29 - $165.99
$8.29
$7.75 - $134.99
$7.75 - $134.99
$7.75
A single Camacho Triple Maduro Toro cigar with a black and silver band, wrapped in clear plastic, is shown against a white background.
An open box of Camacho Triple Maduro Toro by Camacho displays ten full-bodied cigars with black and silver bands, plus one Toro cigar shown separately on the right.

Camacho Triple Maduro Toro

Camacho Cigars
$11.49 - $219.99
$11.49 - $219.99
$11.49 - $219.99
$11.49

If you're the type who doesn’t back down from flavor, Camacho Triple Maduro Toro is calling your name. This all-Maduro blend is one of the boldest ...

View full details
$11.49 - $219.99
$11.49 - $219.99
$11.49 - $219.99
$11.49
A single San Cristobal Quintessence Epicure cigar from San Cristobal Cigars, featuring a decorative colorful band and an Ecuador Habano Rosado wrapper, is displayed against a plain white background.
An open wooden box of San Cristobal Cigars San Cristobal Quintessence Epicure features colorful-banded Nicaraguan cigars, with one Ecuador Habano Rosado-wrapped cigar displayed upright in the foreground.

San Cristobal Quintessence Epicure

San Cristobal Cigars
$11.29 - $276.00
$11.29 - $276.00
$57.50
$11.29 - $252.99
$11.29 - $252.99
$11.29

The San Cristobal Quintessence Epicure is a bold, award-winning cigar that wraps an Ecuador Habano Rosado leaf around vintage Nicaraguan tobaccos f...

View full details
$11.29 - $276.00
$11.29 - $276.00
$57.50
$11.29 - $252.99
$11.29 - $252.99
$11.29
A single Alec Bradley Magic Toast Toro cigar by Alec Bradley Cigars, with a dark Honduran wrapper and decorative label, is displayed on a white background.
An open wooden box of Alec Bradley Cigars’ Magic Toast Toro displays several medium-to-full-bodied cigars, with one cigar close-up to show its intricate band and rich Honduran wrapper.

Alec Bradley Magic Toast Toro

Alec Bradley Cigars
$9.49 - $234.99
$9.49 - $234.99
$9.49 - $234.99
$9.49

Bold yet smooth, the Alec Bradley Magic Toast Toro balances rich earth, cocoa, and spice with a creamy finish that keeps you coming back for more. ...

View full details
$9.49 - $234.99
$9.49 - $234.99
$9.49 - $234.99
$9.49
Factory Smokes by Drew Estate Maduro Toro offers affordable Maduro cigars with dark brown wrappers and stylish black, white, and silver labels from the renowned Drew Estate brand.

Factory Smokes by Drew Estate Maduro Toro

Drew Estate Cigars
$60.00
$2.39 - $60.00
$60.00
$2.39 - $49.99
$2.39 - $49.99
$2.39

Dark, rich, and built for everyday enjoyment, this affordable Maduro-wrapped Toro delivers bold Drew Estate flavor without the premium price tag. ...

View full details
$60.00
$2.39 - $60.00
$60.00
$2.39 - $49.99
$2.39 - $49.99
$2.39
The Founders Roosevelt Maduro Toro by Founders Cigar Co., a brown cigar with a red and gold label and San Andrés Maduro wrapper, is displayed on a white background.
Open wooden box of four Founders Roosevelt Maduro Toro cigars by Founders Cigar Co., each with a San Andrés Maduro wrapper and red-gold band, with one cigar displayed separately on the right.

Founders Roosevelt Maduro Toro

Founders Cigar Co.
$49.99 - $244.99
$49.99 - $244.99
$49.99 - $244.99
$49.99

Bold, adventurous, and built for a long ride, the Roosevelt Maduro channels T.R.’s grit with a dark, medium-bodied profile that’s rich without gett...

View full details
$49.99 - $244.99
$49.99 - $244.99
$49.99 - $244.99
$49.99
A single Deadwood Fat Bottom Betty Toro by Deadwood Tobacco Cigars, featuring a graphic band, is displayed against a white background.
A wooden box of Deadwood Fat Bottom Betty Toro cigars by Deadwood Tobacco Cigars with a lid featuring an illustrated pirate woman; one Maduro cigar is shown close-up, displaying the same signature artwork on its band.

Deadwood Fat Bottom Betty Toro

Deadwood Tobacco Cigars
$11.75 - $117.50
$11.75 - $117.50
$11.75
$10.49 - $102.99
$10.49 - $102.99
$10.49

Bold, sweet, and aromatic, Fat Bottom Betty Toro is a fan-favorite in Drew Estate’s Deadwood lineup, delivering layers of rich flavor with a smooth...

View full details
$11.75 - $117.50
$11.75 - $117.50
$11.75
$10.49 - $102.99
$10.49 - $102.99
$10.49

Every cigar in this collection has one thing in common, consistency. These are the top-performing cigars across the board, favored by both new and seasoned smokers.

You’ll find standout blends from San Cristobal, Camacho, Ashton, and Drew Estate, plus a few up-and-comers that have quickly earned their place among the best. Each one is crafted with precision, aged to perfection, and built to reward your time.

Whether you’re restocking your humidor or exploring what the crowd can’t stop talking about, this lineup makes it easy to pick a winner. Because great cigars just need to deliver each and every time.