Skip to content
Free Shipping on Orders Over $99
Free Shipping on Orders Over $99

Best Selling Cigars

These are the cigars that earned their spot, the ones our customers reach for again and again. From mellow morning smokes to full-bodied powerhouses, every stick here has proven itself through real-world approval. When you’ve put in the work, you deserve a cigar that delivers every single time.

A Buffalo Trace Robusto cigar from Buffalo Trace, featuring a band with an animal illustration and green foil on one end, is shown on a white background.
Open wooden box of Buffalo Trace Robusto cigars, featuring five premium hand-rolled cigars. Close-up shows the cigar band with buffalo illustration and Buffalo Trace branding, inspired by the legendary Kentucky bourbon.

Buffalo Trace Robusto

Buffalo Trace Cigars
$8.19 - $160.99
$8.19 - $160.99
$8.19
$7.49 - $129.99
$7.49 - $129.99
$7.49

Crafted in collaboration with the legendary Buffalo Trace Distillery, the Buffalo Trace Robusto brings the spirit of Kentucky bourbon into a premiu...

View full details
$8.19 - $160.99
$8.19 - $160.99
$8.19
$7.49 - $129.99
$7.49 - $129.99
$7.49
A single Macanudo Cafe Hyde Park Robusto by Macanudo, featuring a decorative band, rests on a plain white background—an iconic Dominican Connecticut cigar ideal for any occasion.
An open box of Macanudo Cafe Hyde Park Robusto cigars by Macanudo reveals neatly arranged Dominican long-fillers, with one Connecticut cigar displayed separately to the right.

Macanudo Cafe Hyde Park Robusto

Macanudo Cigars
$11.19 - $279.75
$11.19 - $279.75
$11.19
$10.49 - $209.99
$10.49 - $209.99
$10.49

The Macanudo Café Hyde Park is a Connecticut-wrapped smooth operator, creamy and mellow with classic nut and toast notes. At 5.5″ x 49, it hits the...

View full details
$11.19 - $279.75
$11.19 - $279.75
$11.19
$10.49 - $209.99
$10.49 - $209.99
$10.49
A single Montecristo White Series Rothschilde cigar by Montecristo, with a mellow profile and an Ecuadorian Connecticut Shade wrapper, accented by a white and gold band, displayed against a plain white background.
An open box of Montecristo White Series Rothschilde by Montecristo displays mellow cigars wrapped in smooth Ecuadorian Connecticut Shade leaf. One cigar stands upright on the right, showing its elegant band.

Montecristo White Series Rothschilde

Montecristo Cigars
$15.92 - $429.84
$15.92 - $429.84
$15.92
$12.99 - $329.99
$12.99 - $329.99
$12.99

Smooth, creamy, and effortlessly elegant, the Montecristo White Rothschilde is a refined take on a timeless classic. If you appreciate mellow cigar...

View full details
$15.92 - $429.84
$15.92 - $429.84
$15.92
$12.99 - $329.99
$12.99 - $329.99
$12.99
A single Perdomo Reserve 10th Anniversary Champagne Robusto cigar is pictured on a white background, featuring a brown Connecticut wrapper and a gold and black label.
An open box of Perdomo Reserve 10th Anniversary Champagne Robusto cigars features one Connecticut cigar close-up, showcasing its gold and yellow band and bourbon barrel-aged wrapper. Brand: Perdomo.

Perdomo Reserve 10th Anniversary Champagne Robusto

Perdomo Cigars
$11.25 - $281.25
$11.25 - $281.25
$11.25
$10.49 - $229.99
$10.49 - $229.99
$10.49

Smooth, elegant, and unexpectedly rich, the Perdomo 10th Anniversary Champagne Robusto is a go-to for those who appreciate nuanced flavor and top-t...

View full details
$11.25 - $281.25
$11.25 - $281.25
$11.25
$10.49 - $229.99
$10.49 - $229.99
$10.49
A single Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real Robusto cigar with a red and gold band and an Ecuadorian Connecticut wrapper rests on a plain white background.
An open box of Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real Robusto cigars by Romeo y Julieta, handcrafted with Nicaraguan long-fillers, with one cigar standing upright beside the box on a white background.

Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real Robusto

Romeo y Julieta Cigars
$10.49 - $249.99
$10.49 - $249.99
$10.49 - $249.99
$10.49

Smooth, spicy, and just bold enough to surprise you, the Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real Robusto rewrites the playbook. This isn’t the mellow 1875 you...

View full details
$10.49 - $249.99
$10.49 - $249.99
$10.49 - $249.99
$10.49
A single Tatuaje Miami Regios ultra-premium cigar, banded near the top and set against a white background, showcases the rich character unique to Tatuaje.
A wooden box of Tatuaje Miami Regios by Tatuaje, featuring brown-wrapped cigars with "Jalapa" bands; one Nicaraguan puro is partially removed and displayed separately.

Tatuaje Miami Regios

Tatuaje Cigars
$20.00 - $30.00
$20.00 - $30.00
$20.00
$12.99 - $309.99
$12.99 - $309.99
$12.99

The Tatuaje Miami Regios is a medium to full-bodied Nicaraguan puro handcrafted in Miami under the eye of Don “Pepin” Garcia and Pete Johnson. Expe...

View full details
$20.00 - $30.00
$20.00 - $30.00
$20.00
$12.99 - $309.99
$12.99 - $309.99
$12.99
A single Warfighter 5.56 Field Connecticut Shade Robusto cigar by Warfighter Tobacco, featuring a dark band with gold accents and logo, rests on a white background.
An open box of Warfighter Tobacco Warfighter 5.56 Field Connecticut Shade Robusto cigars, with several cigars visible inside and one featured in the foreground.

Warfighter 5.56 Field Connecticut Shade Robusto

Warfighter Tobacco Cigars
$10.75 - $209.99
$10.75 - $209.99
$10.75 - $209.99
$10.75

Mellow, smooth, and built for easygoing enjoyment, the 5.56 Field Connecticut Shade Robusto is a mild-to-medium cigar with classic appeal. Cigar I...

View full details
$10.75 - $209.99
$10.75 - $209.99
$10.75 - $209.99
$10.75

Every cigar in this collection has one thing in common, consistency. These are the top-performing cigars across the board, favored by both new and seasoned smokers.

You’ll find standout blends from San Cristobal, Camacho, Ashton, and Drew Estate, plus a few up-and-comers that have quickly earned their place among the best. Each one is crafted with precision, aged to perfection, and built to reward your time.

Whether you’re restocking your humidor or exploring what the crowd can’t stop talking about, this lineup makes it easy to pick a winner. Because great cigars just need to deliver each and every time.