Best Cigars for Valentines Day Gifts

Gifting cigars for Valentine's Day can be a meaningful gift when they’re chosen with a little thought. Whether you’re buying for your husband, partner, or someone you love slowing down with, the right cigar can turn a simple evening into something memorable and personal.

This guide is designed to make choosing easier. Instead of overwhelming you with options, we focus on cigars that work well as gifts: cigars that are enjoyable, balanced, and appropriate for the occasion.

From smooth, easygoing picks to richer cigars for more experienced smokers, these top shelf cigars are selected with real moments in mind. They’re meant to fit naturally into life, whether the celebration is a private dinner together or enjoyed later with friends.

How to Choose the Perfect Valentine’s Day Gift

If you’re buying cigars online as a gift, you don’t need to overthink it, you just need to focus on how the cigar will actually be enjoyed. Valentine’s Day cigars are often part of a relaxed celebration rather than a long or intense smoking session.

Start with strength. A smooth or medium-bodied cigar is usually a safer choice than something heavy, especially if your spouse only smokes occasionally. If you’re not sure what they like, a sampler can be a smart option. It allows them to explore different cigars over time without pressure, and it’s easy to share.

Most importantly, think about the moment. Whether the cigar is enjoyed after dinner, during a quiet night in, or saved for later, the best Valentine’s Day gift are the ones that fit comfortably into the experience without trying too hard to impress.

Top Valentine’s Day Cigars for a Romantic Smoke

These cigars are picked for how they smoke, balanced, enjoyable, and easy to settle in with on a relaxed Valentine’s evening. Whether you’re sharing one together or choosing a thoughtful gift, each of these fits the moment naturally without trying too hard.

Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real Toro

The Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real Toro is a classic choice when you want a Valentine’s Day cigar that feels both elegant and reliably enjoyable. It strikes a nice balance, refined enough to feel special, but smooth enough to appeal to a wide range of smokers. If you want a gift that says you put thought into it without being too intense or overwhelming, this one fits that sweet spot.

Romeo y Julieta is a brand with a long history in premium cigars, and their Reserva Real line continues that tradition with consistent flavor and approachability. The Toro format gives the smoke a bit of presence without demanding a long, heavy session, perfect for a relaxed evening with someone you love.

Key Details:

• Size: Toro (6.0 x 54)

• Wrapper: Ecuadorian Connecticut

• Body: Medium

• Profile: Smooth cedar, soft spice, creamy notes, gentle sweetness

• Best For: Medium-body lovers, evenings, partners who appreciate tradition

Buy Now

Perdomo Reserve 10th Anniversary Champagne Robusto

If you want a safe, “can’t-miss” Valentine’s Day gift, this cigar from Perdomo Cigars is one of the easiest picks you can make. It’s smooth, creamy, and polished without feeling bland, which makes it a great choice whether your partner is newer to cigars or just prefers something refined.

It’s also the kind of cigar that fits a romantic evening naturally, nothing harsh, nothing too aggressive, just an enjoyable smoke that feels like it belongs in the moment.

Key Details:

• Size: Robusto

• Wrapper: Connecticut

• Body: Mild-to-Medium

• Profile: Creamy, smooth, soft cedar, light sweetness

• Best For: Newer smokers, smooth cigar fans, after a Valentine’s Day dinner

Buy Now

San Cristobal Elegancia Imperial

This is a great gift when you want something that feels elevated but still easy to enjoy. The Elegancia from San Cristobal Cigars leans creamy and refined, with a profile that stays balanced from start to finish. It’s the kind of cigar that feels intentional, which is exactly what you want for Valentine’s Day.

If your husband or spouse likes premium cigars but doesn’t necessarily want a powerhouse, this one lands right in that sweet spot: high quality, smooth delivery, and a calm, enjoyable experience.

Key Details:

• Size: 6.0 x 52

• Wrapper: Ecuadorian Connecticut

• Body: Mild-to-Medium

• Profile: Creamy, nuanced, smooth: hints of coffee, toasted almond, cedar, and a touch of pepper

• Best For: An evening smoke, mild-to-medium preference, “refined” profiles

Buy Now

EP Carrillo Pledge Prequel (Box-Pressed)

If you’re buying for someone who really likes cigars and appreciates complexity, this is a strong Valentine’s gift pick. The Pledge by E.P. Carrillo Cigars has depth and richness, but it’s still controlled and well-built. It’s the type of cigar that rewards a slow smoke and fits a “sit back and enjoy it” kind of night.

This is also a great option when you want the gift to feel more “serious” in a good way, like you chose something with reputation behind it.

Key Details:

• Size: 5.0 x 50

• Wrapper: Connecticut Habano

• Body: Medium

• Profile: Rich, bold, layered, darker sweetness, spice

• Best For: Experienced smokers, bold flavor fans, pairing with bourbon

Buy Now

Camacho Triple Maduro Toro

This Camacho Cigars Triple Maduro is a confident pick for a smoker who likes intensity. If you're shopping for someone who loves bold cigars and gravitates toward darker wrappers, this is one of those that delivers what it promises.

It’s not the one you choose for a brand-new cigar smoker, but if you know the recipient likes stronger cigars, this is an excellent choice.

Key Details:

• Size: Toro

• Wrapper: Maduro

• Body: Full

• Profile: Dark, rich, earthy, spice-forward

• Best For: Experienced smokers, full-bodied fans, bourbon pairings

Buy Now

Deadwood Sweet Jane Corona

Sweet Jane is the “fun” Valentine’s Day cigar pick, approachable, flavorful, and easy to enjoy without overthinking it. If your partner likes cigars that lean aromatic or sweet leaning (or they enjoy a more relaxed, casual smoke), this is a great gifting option.

This Deadwood Tobacco cigar is also a really solid choice if you’re not totally sure what they like. It’s got personality, but it doesn’t punish the palate.

Key Details:

• Size: Corona (5.0 x 46)

• Wrapper: Maduro

• Body: Medium-Full

• Profile: Sweet-leaning, aromatic, smooth, easygoing

• Best For: Casual smokers, sweet-leaning profiles, relaxed evenings

Buy Now

Drew Estate Tabak Especial Robusto Dulce

If you want to find a cigar that feels like it belongs after dinner, this is a great choice from Drew Estate. Tabak Dulce is smooth, sweet-leaning, and very approachable, especially for someone who smokes occasionally or prefers cigars that aren’t harsh.

This one works well for Valentine’s Day because it fits naturally with dessert and coffee, and it’s built around an intentional coffee-forward experience (instead of trying to be “strong” for the sake of it).

Key Details:

• Size: Robusto

• Wrapper: Connecticut

• Body: Mild-Full

• Profile: Sweet, smooth, dessert-friendly, coffee-adjacent

• Best For: Newer smokers, sweet-leaning cigars, coffee/dessert pairings

Buy Now

Bold Beginnings Sampler

If you’re not sure what to buy your husband or spouse a cigar sampler is one of the smartest Valentine’s Day cigar gifts you can give—especially if you want your partner to try a few different profiles without guessing wrong.

This sampler is ideal because it gives variety while still keeping things gift-friendly. It’s also perfect for couples, choose one to share together, and save the rest for future “earned moments.”

Key Details:

• Type: Sampler

• Body Range: Varies

• Profile: Variety pack (multiple styles)

• Best For: Gifts for husbands/partners, unsure preferences, shared experiences

Buy Now

Pairing Your Valentine’s Day Cigar

You don’t need a full setup to make the moment feel special. A few simple pairings can add to the experience without taking attention away from the cigar itself.

Smooth cigars pair well with champagne or prosecco, which keeps the mood light and relaxed. Richer cigars tend to work better with bourbon, where deeper flavors can complement each other naturally. Sweet-leaning cigars often shine alongside coffee or dessert, especially when the evening is more about conversation and connection.

The best cigar pairings are about enhancing the passion and romance of the moment. When the cigar fits the setting, everything else feels effortless.

Final Thoughts

The best Valentine’s Day cigars aren’t about checking boxes or buying the most expensive option. They’re about choosing something that fits the person and the moment. A smooth cigar for a relaxed evening or a richer blend for a seasoned smoker can turn a simple gift into a shared experience.

If you’re buying for someone else, it's best to focus on smoothness over intensity unless you know they lean towards stronger blends.  A well-chosen cigar shows your attention, whether it’s enjoyed together or saved for another time. That’s what makes it a meaningful part of the celebration and why cigars continue to be a gift people return to year after year.

Explore a wide variety of cigars from trusted brands, any season, any occasion, at After Action Cigars.