Skip to content
Free Shipping on Orders Over $99
Free Shipping on Orders Over $99

Medium Cigars

Not too light. Not too bold. Medium cigars are where balance lives, and for many, it’s the zone they keep coming back to.

Our selection of medium-bodied cigars hits that perfect middle ground: enough body to keep things interesting, but smooth enough for anytime enjoyment. These blends offer a wide range of flavor profiles, some rich and creamy, others with a subtle spice or a touch of earth, making them a reliable go-to whether you’re lighting up at the end of a long shift or gearing up for an evening with friends.

The Buffalo Trace Toro by Buffalo Trace is a medium-bodied brown cigar with a green band at one end and a portrait label—perfect for pairing with bourbon.
Open wooden box of Buffalo Trace Robusto cigars, featuring five premium hand-rolled cigars. Close-up shows the cigar band with buffalo illustration and Buffalo Trace branding, inspired by the legendary Kentucky bourbon.

Buffalo Trace Toro

Buffalo Trace Cigars
$8.29 - $165.99
$8.29 - $165.99
$8.29
$7.75 - $134.99
$7.75 - $134.99
$7.75

A bold pairing for bourbon lovers, the Buffalo Trace Toro brings the iconic whiskey brand’s signature richness to a medium-bodied, full-flavored ci...

View full details
$8.29 - $165.99
$8.29 - $165.99
$8.29
$7.75 - $134.99
$7.75 - $134.99
$7.75
A Buffalo Trace Robusto cigar from Buffalo Trace, featuring a band with an animal illustration and green foil on one end, is shown on a white background.
Open wooden box of Buffalo Trace Robusto cigars, featuring five premium hand-rolled cigars. Close-up shows the cigar band with buffalo illustration and Buffalo Trace branding, inspired by the legendary Kentucky bourbon.

Buffalo Trace Robusto

Buffalo Trace Cigars
$8.19 - $160.99
$8.19 - $160.99
$8.19
$7.49 - $129.99
$7.49 - $129.99
$7.49

Crafted in collaboration with the legendary Buffalo Trace Distillery, the Buffalo Trace Robusto brings the spirit of Kentucky bourbon into a premiu...

View full details
$8.19 - $160.99
$8.19 - $160.99
$8.19
$7.49 - $129.99
$7.49 - $129.99
$7.49
A brown, pointed-tip cigar with a white band showing an image and green text rests on a white background—ideal for pairing with bourbon. Enjoy rich barrel-aged notes from Buffalo Trace Special F by Buffalo Trace Cigars.
A green box labeled "Buffalo Trace Special F" by Buffalo Trace Cigars features barrel-aged cigars with buffalo imagery; a close-up of one cigar in the foreground highlights its appeal for a premium bourbon pairing.

Buffalo Trace Special F

Buffalo Trace Cigars
$11.90 - $119.00
$11.90 - $119.00
$11.90
$9.49 - $94.99
$9.49 - $94.99
$9.49

The Buffalo Trace Special F is a unique offering crafted for those who appreciate the bold harmony of whiskey and cigars. Made in the Dominican Rep...

View full details
$11.90 - $119.00
$11.90 - $119.00
$11.90
$9.49 - $94.99
$9.49 - $94.99
$9.49
A single Buffalo Trace Churchill cigar by Buffalo Trace, featuring a brown wrapper, green band on one end, and a sepia portrait label near the other, is displayed against a white background to highlight this handcrafted premium cigar.
Open wooden box of Buffalo Trace Robusto cigars, featuring five premium hand-rolled cigars. Close-up shows the cigar band with buffalo illustration and Buffalo Trace branding, inspired by the legendary Kentucky bourbon.

Buffalo Trace Churchill

Buffalo Trace Cigars
$8.50 - $169.99
$8.50 - $169.99
$8.50
$7.99 - $139.99
$7.99 - $139.99
$7.99

A long, smooth draw inspired by America’s favorite bourbon. The Buffalo Trace Churchill offers a refined experience—bold, aromatic, and crafted to ...

View full details
$8.50 - $169.99
$8.50 - $169.99
$8.50
$7.99 - $139.99
$7.99 - $139.99
$7.99

This is the backbone of most humidors for a reason. At After Action Cigars, we stock proven favorites and a few unexpected standouts worth discovering. Whether you’re still dialing in your taste or already know your preferred profile, there’s a medium cigar here with your name on it. Light it. Enjoy it. Then get back after it.