Skip to content
Free Shipping on Orders Over $99
Free Shipping on Orders Over $99

Best Selling Cigars

These are the cigars that earned their spot, the ones our customers reach for again and again. From mellow morning smokes to full-bodied powerhouses, every stick here has proven itself through real-world approval. When you’ve put in the work, you deserve a cigar that delivers every single time.

Factory Smokes by Drew Estate Maduro Toro offers affordable Maduro cigars with dark brown wrappers and stylish black, white, and silver labels from the renowned Drew Estate brand.
Factory Smokes by Drew Estate Maduro Toro
Drew Estate Cigars
$60.00
$2.39 - $60.00
$60.00
$2.39 - $49.99
$2.39 - $49.99
$2.39

Dark, rich, and built for everyday enjoyment, this affordable Maduro-wrapped Toro delivers bold Drew Estate flavor without the premium price tag. ...

View full details
$60.00
$2.39 - $60.00
$60.00
$2.39 - $49.99
$2.39 - $49.99
$2.39
An open Deadwood Tobacco box labeled "Sweet Jane" displays Deadwood Sweet Jane Corona cigars; a close-up shows a detailed band with a woman's face and floral design on one cigar.
An open Deadwood Tobacco box labeled "Sweet Jane" displays Deadwood Sweet Jane Corona cigars; a close-up shows a detailed band with a woman's face and floral design on one cigar.
Deadwood Sweet Jane Corona
Deadwood Tobacco Cigars
$8.99 - $189.99
$8.99 - $189.99
$8.99 - $189.99
$8.99

If you’re after a cigar that doesn’t play by the rules but still delivers a smooth, flavorful ride, Sweet Jane is calling your name. Made by Drew E...

View full details
$8.99 - $189.99
$8.99 - $189.99
$8.99 - $189.99
$8.99
Open wooden box of Buffalo Trace Robusto cigars, featuring five premium hand-rolled cigars. Close-up shows the cigar band with buffalo illustration and Buffalo Trace branding, inspired by the legendary Kentucky bourbon.
Open wooden box of Buffalo Trace Robusto cigars, featuring five premium hand-rolled cigars. Close-up shows the cigar band with buffalo illustration and Buffalo Trace branding, inspired by the legendary Kentucky bourbon.
Buffalo Trace Toro
Buffalo Trace Cigars
$8.29 - $165.99
$8.29 - $165.99
$8.29
$7.75 - $134.99
$7.75 - $134.99
$7.75

A bold pairing for bourbon lovers, the Buffalo Trace Toro brings the iconic whiskey brand’s signature richness to a medium-bodied, full-flavored ci...

View full details
$8.29 - $165.99
$8.29 - $165.99
$8.29
$7.75 - $134.99
$7.75 - $134.99
$7.75
Deadwood Sweet Jane Tins
Deadwood Sweet Jane Tins Sold out
Deadwood Sweet Jane Tins
Deadwood Tobacco Cigars
$19.99 - $84.99
$19.99 - $84.99
$19.99 - $84.99
$19.99

The Deadwood Sweet Jane Tin brings premium cigar flavor into a compact, convenient cigarillo format, crafted by Drew Estate for the bold, the adven...

View full details
$19.99 - $84.99
$19.99 - $84.99
$19.99 - $84.99
$19.99
Sold out
Open wooden box of Buffalo Trace Robusto cigars, featuring five premium hand-rolled cigars. Close-up shows the cigar band with buffalo illustration and Buffalo Trace branding, inspired by the legendary Kentucky bourbon.
Open wooden box of Buffalo Trace Robusto cigars, featuring five premium hand-rolled cigars. Close-up shows the cigar band with buffalo illustration and Buffalo Trace branding, inspired by the legendary Kentucky bourbon.
Buffalo Trace Robusto
Buffalo Trace Cigars
$8.19 - $160.99
$8.19 - $160.99
$8.19
$7.49 - $129.99
$7.49 - $129.99
$7.49

Crafted in collaboration with the legendary Buffalo Trace Distillery, the Buffalo Trace Robusto brings the spirit of Kentucky bourbon into a premiu...

View full details
$8.19 - $160.99
$8.19 - $160.99
$8.19
$7.49 - $129.99
$7.49 - $129.99
$7.49
An open box of Warfighter Tobacco Warfighter 5.56 Field Connecticut Shade Robusto cigars, with several cigars visible inside and one featured in the foreground.
An open box of Warfighter Tobacco Warfighter 5.56 Field Connecticut Shade Robusto cigars, with several cigars visible inside and one featured in the foreground.
Warfighter 5.56 Field Connecticut Shade Toro
Warfighter Tobacco Cigars
$12.25 - $245.00
$12.25 - $245.00
$12.25
$11.29 - $214.99
$11.29 - $214.99
$11.29

Mellow, smooth, and built for easygoing enjoyment, the 5.56 Field Connecticut Shade Toro is a mild-to-medium cigar with classic appeal and a little...

View full details
$12.25 - $245.00
$12.25 - $245.00
$12.25
$11.29 - $214.99
$11.29 - $214.99
$11.29
Big Sky Cigars Blackfoot Toro
Big Sky Cigars Blackfoot Toro
Big Sky Cigars Blackfoot Toro
Big Sky Cigar Co.
$14.79 - $293.99
$14.79 - $293.99
$14.79
$13.99 - $239.99
$13.99 - $239.99
$13.99

The Blackfoot feels built for the outdoors. This is a rich, grounded blend that leans into earth, wood, and steady strength without turning harsh. ...

View full details
$14.79 - $293.99
$14.79 - $293.99
$14.79
$13.99 - $239.99
$13.99 - $239.99
$13.99
An open wooden box of San Cristobal Cigars San Cristobal Quintessence Epicure features colorful-banded Nicaraguan cigars, with one Ecuador Habano Rosado-wrapped cigar displayed upright in the foreground.
An open wooden box of San Cristobal Cigars San Cristobal Quintessence Epicure features colorful-banded Nicaraguan cigars, with one Ecuador Habano Rosado-wrapped cigar displayed upright in the foreground.
San Cristobal Quintessence Epicure
San Cristobal Cigars
$11.29 - $276.00
$11.29 - $276.00
$57.50
$11.29 - $252.99
$11.29 - $252.99
$11.29

The San Cristobal Quintessence Epicure is a bold, award-winning cigar that wraps an Ecuador Habano Rosado leaf around vintage Nicaraguan tobaccos f...

View full details
$11.29 - $276.00
$11.29 - $276.00
$57.50
$11.29 - $252.99
$11.29 - $252.99
$11.29
My Father The Judge Toro Fino
My Father The Judge Toro Fino
My Father The Judge Toro Fino
My Father Cigars
$0.00 - $0.00
$0.00
$13.99 - $269.99
$13.99 - $269.99
$13.99

If you’re looking for a cigar that leans bold, rich, and unapologetically full of flavor, the My Father The Judge Toro Fino delivers in a big way. ...

View full details
$0.00 - $0.00
$0.00
$13.99 - $269.99
$13.99 - $269.99
$13.99
Arturo Fuente Hemingway Best Seller Perfecto
Arturo Fuente Hemingway Best Seller Perfecto
Arturo Fuente Hemingway Best Seller Perfecto
Arturo Fuente Cigars
$9.99 - $219.99
$9.99 - $219.99
$9.99 - $219.99
$9.99

When someone asks for a cigar that shows off the craftsmanship Arturo Fuente is known for, the Hemingway line almost always comes up. The Best Sell...

View full details
$9.99 - $219.99
$9.99 - $219.99
$9.99 - $219.99
$9.99
An open box of Deadwood Tobacco's Deadwood Leather Rose Torpedo cigars features a stylized woman with roses on the box and band, highlighting these bold Brazilian Maduro cigars.
An open box of Deadwood Tobacco's Deadwood Leather Rose Torpedo cigars features a stylized woman with roses on the box and band, highlighting these bold Brazilian Maduro cigars.
Deadwood Leather Rose Torpedo
Deadwood Tobacco Cigars
$9.09 - $204.99
$9.09 - $204.99
$9.09 - $204.99
$9.09

Spicy, aromatic, and unforgettable, this Flavored Maduro torpedo is the bold standout of the Deadwood lineup. Wrapped in a dark, chewy Brazilian Ma...

View full details
$9.09 - $204.99
$9.09 - $204.99
$9.09 - $204.99
$9.09
Warped Cigars La Colmena
Warped Cigars La Colmena
Warped Cigars La Colmena
Warped Cigars
$73.25 - $210.00
$73.25 - $210.00
$73.25
$97.99 - $189.99
$97.99 - $189.99
$97.99

If bold, heavy cigars aren’t always your move and you appreciate nuance, balance, and old-world style, La Colmena is the lane. This blend leans int...

View full details
$73.25 - $210.00
$73.25 - $210.00
$73.25
$97.99 - $189.99
$97.99 - $189.99
$97.99
A wooden box of Tatuaje Miami Regios by Tatuaje, featuring brown-wrapped cigars with "Jalapa" bands; one Nicaraguan puro is partially removed and displayed separately.
A wooden box of Tatuaje Miami Regios by Tatuaje, featuring brown-wrapped cigars with "Jalapa" bands; one Nicaraguan puro is partially removed and displayed separately.
Tatuaje Miami Regios
Tatuaje Cigars
$14.99 - $324.99
$14.99 - $324.99
$14.99
$12.99 - $309.99
$12.99 - $309.99
$12.99

The Tatuaje Miami Regios is a medium to full-bodied Nicaraguan puro handcrafted in Miami by Don “Pepin” Garcia and Pete Johnson. Built around class...

View full details
$14.99 - $324.99
$14.99 - $324.99
$14.99
$12.99 - $309.99
$12.99 - $309.99
$12.99
An open box of Warfighter Tobacco Warfighter 5.56 Field Connecticut Shade Robusto cigars, with several cigars visible inside and one featured in the foreground.
An open box of Warfighter Tobacco Warfighter 5.56 Field Connecticut Shade Robusto cigars, with several cigars visible inside and one featured in the foreground.
Warfighter 5.56 Field Connecticut Shade Robusto
Warfighter Tobacco Cigars
$10.75 - $209.99
$10.75 - $209.99
$10.75 - $209.99
$10.75

Mellow, smooth, and built for easygoing enjoyment, the 5.56 Field Connecticut Shade Robusto is a mild-to-medium cigar with classic appeal. Cigar I...

View full details
$10.75 - $209.99
$10.75 - $209.99
$10.75 - $209.99
$10.75
Tatuaje Reserva Broadleaf Unicos
Tatuaje Reserva Broadleaf Unicos
Tatuaje Reserva Broadleaf Unicos
Tatuaje Cigars
$14.99 - $139.99
$14.99 - $139.99
$14.99
$12.99 - $119.99
$12.99 - $119.99
$12.99

The Tatuaje Reserva Broadleaf Unicos is a medium to full-bodied Nicaraguan cigar wrapped in rich Connecticut Broadleaf and handcrafted at the My Fa...

View full details
$14.99 - $139.99
$14.99 - $139.99
$14.99
$12.99 - $119.99
$12.99 - $119.99
$12.99
Tatuaje Havana VI Nobles
Tatuaje Havana VI Nobles
Tatuaje Havana VI Nobles
Tatuaje Cigars
$8.50 - $192.00
$8.50 - $192.00
$8.50
$7.99 - $169.99
$7.99 - $169.99
$7.99

The Tatuaje Havana VI Nobles is a medium-bodied Nicaraguan cigar blended by Pete Johnson and handcrafted at My Father Cigars. Designed as a more ap...

View full details
$8.50 - $192.00
$8.50 - $192.00
$8.50
$7.99 - $169.99
$7.99 - $169.99
$7.99
Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Umbagog Toro
Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Umbagog Toro
Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Umbagog Toro
Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust
$11.70 - $117.00
$11.70 - $117.00
$11.70
$10.49 - $99.49
$10.49 - $99.49
$10.49

The Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Umbagog Toro Toro is an affordable everyday cigar designed for real life. Yard work, fishing trips, garage hangs,...

View full details
$11.70 - $117.00
$11.70 - $117.00
$11.70
$10.49 - $99.49
$10.49 - $99.49
$10.49
My Father Blue Honduras Toro
My Father Blue Honduras Toro
Sold out
My Father Blue Honduras Toro
My Father Cigars
$0.00 - $0.00
$0.00
$12.99 - $229.99
$12.99 - $229.99
$12.99

If you’re looking to branch out from the usual Nicaraguan-heavy profiles and try something with a different kind of depth, the My Father Blue Hondu...

View full details
$0.00 - $0.00
$0.00
$12.99 - $229.99
$12.99 - $229.99
$12.99
Sold out
Montecristo Platinum Toro
Montecristo Platinum Toro
Montecristo Platinum Toro
Montecristo Cigars
$14.49 - $369.99
$14.49 - $369.99
$14.49 - $369.99
$14.49

If you’re looking for a step up from the classic Montecristo profile, the Montecristo Platinum Toro brings more body, more richness, and a deeper, ...

View full details
$14.49 - $369.99
$14.49 - $369.99
$14.49 - $369.99
$14.49
Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Belicoso
Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Belicoso
Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Belicoso
Arturo Fuente Cigars
$15.49 - $383.75
$15.49 - $383.75
$76.75
$15.49 - $326.19
$15.49 - $326.19
$15.49

When someone asks for a cigar that’s refined, balanced, and built on tradition, the Don Carlos line always enters the conversation. The Belicoso vi...

View full details
$15.49 - $383.75
$15.49 - $383.75
$76.75
$15.49 - $326.19
$15.49 - $326.19
$15.49
Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Mi Querida Ancho Largo
Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Mi Querida Ancho Largo
Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Mi Querida Ancho Largo
Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust
$14.99 - $293.00
$14.99 - $293.00
$14.99
$13.99 - $239.99
$13.99 - $239.99
$13.99

If you’re the type of smoker who prefers cigars with depth and that old-school maduro character, the Mi Querida Ancho Largo is right in your wheelh...

View full details
$14.99 - $293.00
$14.99 - $293.00
$14.99
$13.99 - $239.99
$13.99 - $239.99
$13.99
Camacho Ecuador Toro
Camacho Ecuador Toro
Camacho Ecuador Toro
Camacho Cigars
$10.30 - $206.00
$10.30 - $206.00
$10.30
$9.49 - $184.99
$9.49 - $184.99
$9.49

If you like cigars that bring energy, character, and a little edge without going overboard, the Camacho Ecuador Toro sits in a sweet spot. This is ...

View full details
$10.30 - $206.00
$10.30 - $206.00
$10.30
$9.49 - $184.99
$9.49 - $184.99
$9.49
An open wooden box of Alec Bradley Cigars’ Magic Toast Toro displays several medium-to-full-bodied cigars, with one cigar close-up to show its intricate band and rich Honduran wrapper.
An open wooden box of Alec Bradley Cigars’ Magic Toast Toro displays several medium-to-full-bodied cigars, with one cigar close-up to show its intricate band and rich Honduran wrapper.
Alec Bradley Magic Toast Toro
Alec Bradley Cigars
$9.49 - $234.99
$9.49 - $234.99
$9.49 - $234.99
$9.49

Bold yet smooth, the Alec Bradley Magic Toast Toro balances rich earth, cocoa, and spice with a creamy finish that keeps you coming back for more. ...

View full details
$9.49 - $234.99
$9.49 - $234.99
$9.49 - $234.99
$9.49
An open box of Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real Robusto cigars by Romeo y Julieta, handcrafted with Nicaraguan long-fillers, with one cigar standing upright beside the box on a white background.
An open box of Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real Robusto cigars by Romeo y Julieta, handcrafted with Nicaraguan long-fillers, with one cigar standing upright beside the box on a white background.
Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real Robusto
Romeo y Julieta Cigars
$10.49 - $249.99
$10.49 - $249.99
$10.49 - $249.99
$10.49

Smooth, spicy, and just bold enough to surprise you, the Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real Robusto rewrites the playbook. This isn’t the mellow 1875 you...

View full details
$10.49 - $249.99
$10.49 - $249.99
$10.49 - $249.99
$10.49
Open wooden box of four Founders Roosevelt Maduro Toro cigars by Founders Cigar Co., each with a San Andrés Maduro wrapper and red-gold band, with one cigar displayed separately on the right.
Open wooden box of four Founders Roosevelt Maduro Toro cigars by Founders Cigar Co., each with a San Andrés Maduro wrapper and red-gold band, with one cigar displayed separately on the right.
Founders Roosevelt Maduro Toro
Founders Cigar Co.
$49.99 - $244.99
$49.99 - $244.99
$49.99 - $244.99
$49.99

Bold, adventurous, and built for a long ride, the Roosevelt Maduro channels T.R.’s grit with a dark, medium-bodied profile that’s rich without gett...

View full details
$49.99 - $244.99
$49.99 - $244.99
$49.99 - $244.99
$49.99
A wooden box of Deadwood Fat Bottom Betty Toro cigars by Deadwood Tobacco Cigars with a lid featuring an illustrated pirate woman; one Maduro cigar is shown close-up, displaying the same signature artwork on its band.
A wooden box of Deadwood Fat Bottom Betty Toro cigars by Deadwood Tobacco Cigars with a lid featuring an illustrated pirate woman; one Maduro cigar is shown close-up, displaying the same signature artwork on its band.
Deadwood Fat Bottom Betty Toro
Deadwood Tobacco Cigars
$11.75 - $117.50
$11.75 - $117.50
$11.75
$10.49 - $102.50
$10.49 - $102.50
$10.49

Bold, sweet, and aromatic, Fat Bottom Betty Toro is a fan-favorite in Drew Estate’s Deadwood lineup, delivering layers of rich flavor with a smooth...

View full details
$11.75 - $117.50
$11.75 - $117.50
$11.75
$10.49 - $102.50
$10.49 - $102.50
$10.49

Every cigar in this collection has one thing in common, consistency. These are the top-performing cigars across the board, favored by both new and seasoned smokers.

You’ll find standout blends from San Cristobal, Camacho, Ashton, and Drew Estate, plus a few up-and-comers that have quickly earned their place among the best. Each one is crafted with precision, aged to perfection, and built to reward your time.

Whether you’re restocking your humidor or exploring what the crowd can’t stop talking about, this lineup makes it easy to pick a winner. Because great cigars just need to deliver each and every time.