It’s a question we get all the time, “Can I smoke half a cigar now and relight it later?”
Whether it’s an early meeting, bad weather, or life just getting in the way, every cigar smoker has faced it. The idea makes sense, cigars aren’t cheap, and wasting half a good one definitely stings, but the reality isn’t as simple as lighting it back up.
Here’s our take: while you can relight a half-smoked cigar, we don’t usually recommend it. The flavor and aroma you’ll get the second time around just aren’t the same.
Once a cigar has cooled, the oils, tar, and ash left behind will always change how it tastes and burns. In our experience, the juice isn’t worth the squeeze.
Another common question we get asked all the time is, “Can you relight a cigar and have it taste the same?” Even cigar purists would agree that the flavors are never quite identical.
That said, we completely understand the temptation. Life happens. Maybe you started a cigar and had to step away, or you didn’t realize how little time you had before lighting up. Whatever the case, you’re left with a good half of a cigar and the urge to save it for later, and if you’re going to do it, there’s a right way to go about it.
Below, we’ll walk you through what actually happens when a cigar goes out, how to store it, and how to relight it as cleanly as possible if you decide to give it another shot.
Even the best-laid smoke sessions sometimes get cut short. You might have to step away for work, deal with unexpected weather, or simply decide you’ve had enough for now. Cigars are meant to be enjoyed slowly, not rushed, so putting one down halfway isn’t a crime.
The good news? If you handle that cigar correctly, you can come back later and pick up where you left off. While not ideal, nor recommended, the key is knowing how to keep it as fresh as possible to relight without ruining the flavor.
Once a cigar goes out, a few things start happening inside the tobacco. The oils that carry the cigar’s flavor begin to dry, and the leftover smoke and tar in the foot (the end you light) start to settle. If you just leave it sitting out, air and humidity combine to dull the aroma and create that bitter, stale taste you’ve probably noticed from an old ashtray.
Even the burn line tells a story: when a cigar goes out or if your cigar burns unevenly with too much ash left on, that area will relight poorly. A cigar’s burn line and burn issues depend on humidity, construction, and airflow, all of which change once it’s been put out.
Understanding what’s going on helps you prevent those issues and keep your next light clean and smooth.
The shorter the wait, the better. Ideally, you’ll relight your cigar within a few hours. After four to six hours, the flavor starts to fade, and by the next day, the tobacco can taste flat or harsh.
If you plan to finish it later that same day, store it in a cool, dry place away from air exposure, like a small sealed plastic bag or cigar tube. Leaving it out overnight or in humid air will cause the wrapper to absorb moisture and throw off the draw.
Think of it like leftovers: it’s best when it’s still fresh.
How you put out a cigar determines your success at relighting it later. The best way to extinguish it cleanly is to let it die out naturally; never mash or crush the end. Here’s how to do it properly:
Don’t crush it. Just set it down in the ashtray and let it go out on its own. Crushing forces burnt ash and tar back into the tobacco.
Gently tap the ash. Once cool, knock off any loose bits so you don't reignite the old ash later.
Cut the foot. Use a sharp cigar cutter to remove about half an inch from the burnt end; this eliminates the most bitter area.
Cool it down. Make sure it’s completely cool before storing; residual heat can trap moisture and stale air.
Short-term storage only. If you plan to relight within a few hours, a resealable plastic bag or travel tube will do the trick. Anything longer than that, and you’re better off grabbing a fresh cigar; never put a half-smoked one back in your humidor. It’ll ruin the aroma and flavor of every cigar inside.
If you’re still learning the finer points of cigar care, check out our guides on how to light a cigar properly and How to store cigars without a humidor.
When you’re ready to light a cigar that’s been sitting for a while, patience pays off. Follow these steps for the cleanest relight possible:
Trim the edge again if needed. If it’s been sitting overnight, clip a little more from the foot to expose fresh tobacco.
Purge before lighting. Blow gently through the cigar to push out any stale air or residual gases.
Toast the foot. Use a butane torch or cedar spill; avoid matches with sulfur tips. Hold the flame just off the tobacco and rotate the cigar slowly to create an even toast.
Relight with control. As the edges glow, take a few short puffs to pull the flame in. Rotate again to keep the burn line even, and use caution not to overheat the wrapper; too much flame, too fast, makes the smoke taste hot and harsh.
Take it slow. Don’t rush your draws; letting the cigar heat evenly restores flavor and smoothness.
Every cigar smoker knows half the enjoyment is the ritual, cutting a cigar, toasting, and watching that perfect burn develop. Done this way, you’ll minimize harshness and avoid reigniting old ash or tar.
Every cigar smoker eventually learns the hard way, relighting in a gust of wind or on your lap is never a good idea.
Even experienced cigar smokers slip up when relighting. A few pitfalls to avoid:
Lighting over ash. Always remove ash before applying flame; otherwise, you’re just burning debris.
Skipping the purge. That first puff after storage can taste bitter if you don’t clear it out.
Relighting too fast. If the cigar is still warm, tar and oils can ignite unevenly, creating a harsh draw.
Over-toasting. Holding the torch too close can char the wrapper and ruin the flavor profile.
A little patience and technique go a long way here.
Relighting inevitably changes the flavor; no way around it. The real question is how much? The first few draws might have a faint charred note, but a clean cut and proper relight can restore most of the original profile.
The lingering oils and a soft cap can also affect draw consistency. If the cap’s been pinched or handled too much, expect a tighter pull. Some notes that were once rich or creamy can turn sharp or metallic after relighting, depending on the tobacco blend.
Using a cedar spill or butane torch helps because both produce a neutral flame. Once the cigar heats back up, you’ll often find the core flavors return, just a bit mellower. It won’t be quite the same as a fresh stick, but it’s far from wasted.
Here’s the honest truth: while you can relight a half-smoked cigar, most seasoned smokers, ourselves included, don’t recommend it. The flavor and aroma just don’t hold up the way they did the first time around.
Once a cigar’s been smoked halfway, it’s absorbed moisture, heat, and combustion byproducts that change how the tobacco burns. Even if you try to save it for later, the oils and tar that settle into the foot will always add a bit of harshness when you relight.
Cigar makers design each stick to burn and breathe in one session; the craftsmanship behind that balance is part of the experience. It doesn’t matter how good the cigar is or what box it came from; once it’s been smoked halfway, that balance is gone.
And here’s the big one: don’t ever toss a half-smoked cigar into your humidor thinking you’ll come back to it later. The stale smoke smell will cling to the cedar and taint every cigar in there. When time’s short, call it, grab a new one when you can actually sit down and enjoy it.
You’re better off keeping a few smaller cigars, like coronas, robustos, or cigarillos, around for those quick smoke sessions. They’ll burn cleaner, deliver the same satisfaction, and let you enjoy the full experience from start to finish instead of trying to revive a used one.
We get it, this topic sparks a lot of debate among cigar smokers. Whether it’s curiosity or practicality, these are the same questions that pop up in every lounge and inbox. Below, we’ve answered the most common ones about relighting cigars and storing half-smoked sticks so you know what’s worth trying (and what’s better left alone).
If you’re new to cigar care or curious about the etiquette behind when to relight, pass, or properly put one down, check out our Cigar Etiquette 101 guide for more insight into doing things the right way.
Technically, yes, but it’s not something we’d recommend. Once a cigar sits for more than a few hours, the oils and tar in the tobacco dry out and settle. When you relight it the next day, that stale flavor overpowers everything you enjoyed the first time. You’ll get more bitterness than smoke. If it’s been more than a few hours, just grab a new one.
A few hours at most. After four to six hours, the flavor starts to fade, and by the next morning, it’s gone. The tobacco dries unevenly, and the draw becomes tight and harsh. If you absolutely need to save it short-term, let it cool completely and seal it in a small plastic bag or tube. After that, it’s not worth saving.
No, we highly suggest avoiding this. The stale smoke smell from a half-smoked cigar will seep into the cedar and ruin every fresh cigar in that humidor. Once a cigar’s been lit, it belongs nowhere near your collection. If you can’t finish it soon, toss it, your humidor and your future smokes will thank you.
Once a cigar cools, tar and smoke residue collect in the foot, and the oils that carried its flavor dry up. When you relight it, you’re essentially burning old tar and stale smoke. That’s what gives it that sharp, bitter taste and uneven burn.
You can, but it’s not ideal. Once you cut a cigar, it starts to dry out quickly unless you keep it in a properly maintained humidor. It won’t ruin the cigar like relighting does, but you’ll lose some freshness and aroma if it sits too long.
No. The experience you’ll get when you relight rarely justifies the effort. Cigars are made to be enjoyed in one session; that’s part of their craftsmanship. If you don’t have time for a full smoke, choose a smaller cigar or cigarillo instead. You’ll enjoy every puff and never have to compromise flavor or freshness.
Yes, it’s technically possible to relight a half-smoked cigar, but that doesn’t mean you should. The experience tends to be subpar, and the risk of tainting your humidor or spoiling a good flavor profile often outweighs the reward.
We’d rather light a new one and enjoy those first few puffs the way they were meant to taste, fresh, clean, and unhurried.
At After Action Cigars, we believe cigars are meant to be savored, not stretched. When you know you’re short on time, reach for something smaller and make every puff count. That’s a better smoke, every time.
Cigar etiquette isn’t one-size-fits-all. The rules shift depending on where you are, who you’re with, and how your smoke affects the space around you. Smoking a cigar indoors comes with different responsibilities and considerations than lighting up outside, and knowing...
Cigar smoking has always been more than just lighting up a cigar, it’s about slowing down, appreciating craftsmanship, and respecting those around you. Whether you’re in a cigar lounge, out on the golf course, or winding down at home, good...
It’s a question we get all the time, “Can I smoke half a cigar now and relight it later?” Whether it’s an early meeting, bad weather, or life just getting in the way, every cigar smoker has faced it. The...
