Cigars $9 and Up

Sort by

View as

Don Pepin Garcia Blue Toro Gordo

My Father Cigars

$12.40 - $260.00

$12.40

$12.99 - $234.99

$12.99

If you want the cigar that helped define modern Nicaraguan spice, this is it. The Don Pepín García Blue label is a direct reflection of Pepín Garcí...

View full details

$12.40 - $260.00

$12.40

$12.99 - $234.99

$12.99

88%

(117)

11%

(15)

(0)

(1)

Great everyday smoke

Really clean, mellow profile with cream, light wood, and just a faint hint of spice. If you’re looking for a mild-to-medium cigar that won’t overpower your palate, this is a good pick. For me, I’d sometimes like just a bit more depth of flavor, but the construction and smooth draw made it easy to enjoy. A dependable everyday option.

Enjoyable and Mellow

This Macanudo Hyde Park Robusto was exactly what I wanted for a calm evening smoke. Very smooth from start to finish, with soft cedar and creamy notes carrying through. Mild spice shows up but never overwhelms. Burn was nice and even and the draw stayed effortless. Perfect choice when you want a mellow smoke that still feels satisfying.

Smooth

Smooth, creamy, and easy on the palate. I did find it a little milder than I expected, especially if you’re used to fuller cigars. Still a well-made stick with a great draw and even burn, just might be better suited for those who prefer lighter profiles.

Great flavors, just a little hot

Really enjoyed the peppery kick and rich tobacco flavors in this Toro, but about halfway through it got a tad hot for my taste. That said, construction was solid, and the spice backed off nicely toward the end. Good cigar overall just be ready for some bold notes early on.

Smooth draw

I grabbed the Shady Moose Toro on a recommendation, and it didn’t disappoint. Flavor leaned rich with coffee and dark chocolate notes, but it stayed smooth and approachable. Draw was great right from the first puff and the burn stayed even most of the way. Fun branding but this baby smokes serious. Definitely worth picking up a few more.

1 2 3

Let customers speak for us